Extreme Temperature Diary- Wednesday September 3rd, 2025/ Main Topic: Dozens of Scientists Find Errors in a New Energy Department Climate Report

Climate scientists find errors in a new DOE climate report : NPR

Climate

Dozens of scientists find errors in a new Energy Department climate report

Headshot of Julia Simon

Julia Simon

A group of more than 85 scientists have issued a joint rebuttal to a recent U.S. Department of Energy report about climate change, finding it full of errors and misrepresenting climate science.

This comes weeks after the Union of Concerned Scientists and the Environmental Defense Fund filed a lawsuit against the Trump administration that alleges that Energy Secretary Chris Wright “quietly arranged for five hand-picked skeptics of the effects of climate change” to compile the government’s climate report and violated the law by creating the report in secret with authors “of only one point of view.”

The DOE’s Climate Working Group consisted of four scientists and one economist who have all questioned the scientific consensus that climate change is a large threat to the world and sometimes frame global warming as beneficial.

The group of climate scientists found several examples where the DOE authors cherry-picked or misrepresented climate science in the agency’s report. For instance, in the DOE report the authors claim that rising carbon dioxide can be a “net benefit” to U.S. agriculture, neglecting to mention the negative impacts of more heat and climate-change fueled extreme weather events on crops.

The DOE report also states that there is no evidence of more intense “meteorological” drought in the U.S. or globally, referring to droughts that involve low rainfall. But the dozens of climate scientists point out that this is misleading, because higher temperatures and more evaporation — not just low rainfall — can lead to and exacerbate droughts. They say that there are, in fact, many studies showing how climate change has exacerbated droughts.

“This report was reviewed internally by a group of DOE scientific researchers and policy experts from the Office of Science and National Labs,” writes Ben Dietderich, chief spokesperson for the DOE in an email to NPR.

Dietderich adds that “the Trump administration is committed to engaging in a more thoughtful and science-based conversation about climate change and energy.”

The Trump administration wants the government to stop regulating climate pollution. The DOE report was cited multiple times by the Environmental Protection Agency in its recent proposal to roll back what’s known as the endangerment finding, which is the basis for rules regulating climate pollution, including from coal and gas-fired power plantscars and trucks, and methane from the oil and gas industry.

The DOE report “is about providing fodder for further actions down the track, which will roll back progress on climate action,” says John Cook, a senior research fellow at the University of Melbourne who studies climate science misinformation. “ The DOE report is basically arguing climate change is no big deal, therefore we shouldn’t act. Always it’s about trying to delay action and maintain the status quo.”

The group of more than 85 scientists recently submitted their review of the Climate Working Group report to the Federal Register as part of the DOE’s 30-day open-comment period, which closes on Tuesday.

Andrew Dessler, professor of atmospheric sciences at Texas A&M University, coordinated the response from dozens of climate experts. He says unlike the DOE report, climate reports from groups such as the United Nations’ Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change feature the work of hundreds of global scientists and require multiple rounds of peer review.

Dessler argues that this DOE report, released in late July, is important to pay attention to, because of what he and other scientists identify as problems with the science, and because of how the report is being used by the Trump administration to roll back the endangerment finding. EPA administrator Lee Zeldin has said the goal of the administration is “driving a dagger straight into the heart of the climate change religion.”

Travis Fisher is the director of energy and environmental policy studies at the Cato Institute, a libertarian think tank. He coordinated the work of the DOE’s Climate Working Group. He says the DOE would look at what comes in during the open-comment period.

“If there are errors, they’ll correct them, of course,” Fisher says. “And I don’t know if any group like this could produce a 150-page document without any errors. So we’ll see what comes up.”

Fisher adds,  ”It’s just a matter of good government and good science to address all comments that come in.”

https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1963309328993009666
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1963225382200459560
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1963296984577569248
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1963189144353456535
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1963207604970078509
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1962990345664274774
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1963037200444190927

https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1963255663972200449
https://twitter.com/NWSEastern/status/1963316322793554277
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963243950665265494
https://twitter.com/WeatherProf/status/1962488256840237527
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963240092040069359
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963241030909935818
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963247492964762100

https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963239389624209555
https://twitter.com/sfchronicle/status/1963069489471193136
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963243211230720128
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963246672882065487
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963248253463396433
https://twitter.com/NHC_Atlantic/status/1963214225058185609
https://twitter.com/JohnMoralesTV/status/1963213375384465491

https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963240556529872960
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963242194317266948
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963242801136619726
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963249463717507179
https://twitter.com/JigarShahDC/status/1963074904141529593
https://twitter.com/sfchronicle/status/1963215449648222549
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963245384773583213
https://twitter.com/FinPlanKaluAja1/status/1963171344922841159
https://twitter.com/BrentToderian/status/1962733750581895308

https://twitter.com/RevYearwood/status/1963247371506139305
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963244405319704936
https://twitter.com/CCLSVN/status/1963244768302907590

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *