Extreme Temperature Diary- Thursday May 22nd, 2025/Main Topic: Arctic Clouds Blamed for Underestimating Global Warming in Climate Models

https://www.euronews.com/green/2025/05/21/why-climate-models-are-getting-arctic-warming-wrong-and-how-scientists-are-fixing-them

Why climate models miss the mark on Arctic warming – and how scientists are improving their accuracy

By Craig Saueurs

Researchers have also warned that even limiting global warming to 1.5°C won’t save our polar ice sheets.

If you’re wondering why Arctic temperatures are rising so much faster than predicted, scientists at Kyushu University think they’ve found an answer: it’s in the clouds.

In a study published in Ocean-Land-Atmosphere Research, researchers from Kyushu University analysed 30 leading climate models and compared them to satellite observations of Arctic cloud patterns. They discovered a widespread modelling error.

Most simulations overestimate the amount of ice and underestimate the amount of liquid in wintertime Arctic clouds.

That may sound like a small detail, but it has big consequences for how accurately scientists can predict warming in one of the world’s most sensitive regions.

Clouds could be acting like a thermal blanket over the Arctic

The Arctic is warming three to four times faster than the global average. A major reason for this is how clouds interact with heat.

In summer, so-called mixed-phase clouds – which contain both ice crystals and supercooled liquid water – reflect sunlight, cooling the surface. But in the dark winter months, these same clouds trap heat and insulate the surface like a thermal blanket.

“The more liquid water these clouds contain, the better they are at trapping heat,” explains study co-author Momoka Nakanishi.

Related

Most models, however, suggest that clouds have less ice in them than they do. That could explain why the rate of Arctic warming in recent decades has outpaced predictions. It could also warp future projections – but not in the way you might think.

The future may be less dire than it seems – but the present is worse

As the Arctic continues to warm, more ice in clouds converts to liquid, increasing their heat-trapping power. This creates a short-term condition known as “cloud emissivity feedback,” which accelerates warming. But, the researchers add, there’s a limit to it.

Once clouds are rich enough in liquid, they begin to absorb heat and re-emit it to Earth completely. Meaning, additional warming makes little difference, because the clouds are already re-emitting heat to the maximum extent possible.

Since many climate models don’t accurately represent how much liquid is already present, they could be predicting greater warming than is likely in the future.

In other words, they underestimate today’s warming and overestimate tomorrow’s.

Fixing this flaw, researchers argue, could improve not just Arctic projections but also extreme weather forecasts in other parts of the world, which are influenced by polar systems.

The damage could already be done

The study adds context to another sobering piece of research, published earlier this month in Communications Earth & Environment.

That study found that even if global warming is limited to 1.5°C, we could still trigger irreversible melting in the massive polar ice sheets in Greenland and Antarctica, leading sea levels to rise several metres even under optimistic emissions scenarios.

Related

Both studies point to the same truth: our understanding of polar regions, from clouds to ice melt, is still catching up with reality.

If climate models continue to lag observed trends, the world could be blindsided by faster-than-expected changes in sea level, weather extremes and ecosystem collapse.

As cloud study co-author Takuro Michibata put it, “Fixing these models is essential not just for the Arctic, but for understanding its impact on weather and climate change across the globe.”

Read more

Deborah/Flickr

Urban wilding in action: Breda becomes EU’s first National Park City

The 145m-long Annelies Ilena, the world's largest fishing vessel.

Investigation exposes the ‘sprawling empire’ of 5 Dutch fishing giants

 A pair of North Atlantic right whales interact at the surface of Cape Cod Bay.

Lack of endangered whale babies raises alarm among scientists

https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1925538637652877508
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1925600005169053856
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1925260224127995916
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1925496283776614894
https://twitter.com/yangyubin1998/status/1925558449137750053
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1925325734609834019
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1925469576029958632
https://twitter.com/extremetemps/status/1925299763093664129

If you are looking for climate visualizations using a "pre-industrial" baseline (1850-1900) for calculating anomalies, I update quite a few each month at zacklabe.com/climate-chan… (updated through April 2025)

Zack Labe (@zacklabe.com) 2025-05-22T02:57:47.599Z

It's outrageous that NASA GISS, one of the best earth & space science labs in the world, is being kicked out of its Columbia home. The outstanding scientists who work there can't say that publicly, but I can. And so can you — call your reps, esp. (but not only) if you live in NYC or NY state.

Adam Sobel (@adamsobel.bsky.social) 2025-05-21T16:45:47.513Z

Beyond the Ice- article from Protect our Winters- on the ongoing 42 year long project. @jillpelto.bsky.social

Mauri Pelto (@mauri-pelto.bsky.social) 2025-05-21T23:27:51.738Z

I've been following this for a long time now — the direct effect on home values from #climate change. This now takes it further, to #credit risk and #mortgage underwriting. Really important for every homeowner to understand.#realestate #realestateinvesting

Diana Olick (@dianaolick.bsky.social) 2025-05-19T17:57:08.127Z

Australian company Energy Australia's been forced to admit that offsetting fossil fuel emissions through land sector storage does not prevent harm from those emissions. We warned about the scientific concerns on offsets in this 2023 report #auspol #climateclimateanalytics.org/publications…

Climate Analytics (@climateanalytics.org) 2025-05-21T06:27:58.741Z

"Should we really have fossil fuel subsidies? Is there actually an economy on a dead planet?"

Michael E. Mann (@michaelemann.bsky.social) 2025-05-21T17:21:51.228Z

Trump’s USDA tried to erase climate data. This lawsuit forced it back online.The agency quietly removed web pages on rural energy, climate-smart agriculture, and federal loans — until farmers sued.grist.org/food-and-agr…#Data #USDA #Climate #food #agriculture #Farmers #Farms

Grist (@grist.org) 2025-05-19T15:37:53.207Z

#OurFragileMoment: How Lesson’s From Earth’s Past Can Help Us Survive The Climate Crisis | My recent lecture at @exeter.ac.uk @gsiexeter.bsky.social, with references to Gordon Sumner, The Police, Carl Sagan & more: www.youtube.com/watch?v=W3ep…#GSIExeter

Michael E. Mann (@michaelemann.bsky.social) 2025-05-21T15:57:36.257Z

NOAA just released its first 2025 hurricane season outlook, but there's trouble brewing inside the agency tasked with keeping our coastlines safe that has me most concerned. I've been speaking with trusted colleagues at NWS and have all the details in today's newsletter ⬇️

Michael Lowry (@michaelrlowry.bsky.social) 2025-05-22T16:55:35.939Z
https://twitter.com/ContentWxGuy/status/1925604873325687185

A sobering look at some key #climate indicators from last year -CO2 Emissions in 2024 – Record HighCoal – Record HighGas – Record HighOil – Record High (tied 2019)🧵1/9 www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-glo…

Dr. Aaron Thierry (@thierryaaron.bsky.social) 2025-05-19T11:48:27.660Z

In a shocking move, AustralianSuper has just bought 1.3M shares in the country's largest coal producer, Whitehaven – insisting this is consistent with its 2050 net zero #climate commitments.AustralianSuper, not sure how you missed it, but coal emits a shitload.

Market Forces (@marketforces.org.au) 2025-05-19T23:59:45.175Z

🎥We have the solutions to reduce CO2 emissions and enhance natural carbon sinks.More and more people are changing their behaviour and take #ClimateAction to address #ClimateChange. Are you?learn more 📖 wwf.org.uk/what-we-do/c…PL RP Thank you! 🩷💚💙original graph from WWF #climate #Klima

My Zero Carbon #ClimateAction (@myzerocarbon.org) 2025-05-20T12:59:53.547Z

For years, Phil Anschutz has been building America's largest wind farm in rural Wyoming.Soon after Donald Trump returned to office, the project got a rebranding. Now it's all about "American-made energy," and it includes a gigantic gas plant.My story: www.latimes.com/environment/…

Sammy Roth (@sammyroth.bsky.social) 2025-05-22T17:47:21.702Z
https://twitter.com/cybertruck/status/1925570270288650717

This is some bullshit“The NSF polar office has awarded 88 percent less money in grants this year.”This would take standard ~10% funding rates down to 1%.No wonder my program officer was forbidden from telling me the funding rate after we were rejected www.nytimes.com/interactive/…

Tim Bartholomaus (@timbartholomaus.bsky.social) 2025-05-22T17:38:31.087Z

Indigenous leaders push for seat at the table of high seas biodiversity treaty. Negotiators are calling for involvement in the agreement’s decision-making process, not just an acknowledgement of their presence.grist.org/global-indig…#Biodiversity#Indigenous #Climate #Oceans #Seas #Sealife

Grist (@grist.org) 2025-05-19T16:57:40.051Z

If you’re looking for an encouragement and meaning in life, I really appreciated the thoughts of my colleague @theplantprof.bsky.social here.As I often say, they won’t put your academic CV on your tombstone. So what really matters in life?

Katharine Hayhoe (@katharinehayhoe.com) 2025-05-20T21:02:28.322Z

The EPA is rolling back drinking water limits for 4 PFAS. Thousands more remain unregulated.Experts say it’s past time to regulate "forever chemicals" as a class.grist.org/regulation/e…#EPA #PFAS #Chemicals #Water #Climate #Environment #Pollution

Grist (@grist.org) 2025-05-21T15:54:22.800Z
https://twitter.com/WildernessWatch/status/1925607693387284806

🦋 Good Night Everyone 🦋 ~~~ Sweet Dreams ~~~#Photography#Nature#Climate#Northumberland#GoldenHourENJOYING THE SEA AIR ANC THE BEST PART OF THE DAY 🌊 🌊 🌊

Karen Barry-Davies (@wheelan.bsky.social) 2025-05-20T21:43:02.040Z

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *