Extreme Temperature Diary- Sunday August 23rd, 2026/Main Topic: Bigger, Hotter Fires Are Slowly Erasing America’s Great Western Forests

Wildfires Are Turning Forests in the American West Into Shrubland – The New York Times

Bigger, Hotter Fires Are Slowly Erasing America’s Great Forests

Towering woodlands in the West are being permanently replaced by tracts of spiky shrubs. Conditions “just aren’t normal anymore,” one researcher said.

By Eric Niiler

Photographs and Video by Nic Coury

Reporting from the Sierra National Forest in California

On a gentle slope on the western side of the Sierra Nevada Mountains, where a towering green canopy of ponderosa pines had stood for centuries, wildfires have transformed roughly 1,700 acres into brown, bare shrubland.

That forest is gone for good, scientists say. Spiky shrubs and poison oak have replaced the majestic trees. All that is left of the pines are burned logs and dead branches.

It’s part of a wider transformation that’s taking place across the Western United States, from Oregon to New Mexico, as bigger and hotter wildfires sweep through forests that have not evolved to survive such high-intensity blazes and a warmer climate. Recent studies estimate that as much as 40 percent of Western conifer forests will turn into shrubland by 2100 as a result.

“This is a permanent shift from one ecosystem type to a fundamentally different one,” said Winslow Hansen, a forest ecologist at the Cary Institute of Ecosystem Studies, an independent research center in Millbrook, N.Y.

The consequences of the shift, for both people and wildlife, are expected to be profound.

Researchers say that as trees disappear, winter and spring snow will melt faster, affecting wildlife as well as communities that are already struggling with water shortages. Some Western states get as much as 75 percent of their water from snowmelt.

“When you remove the forest, that snow is more susceptible to melting earlier,” said Benjamin Hatchett, an interdisciplinary scientist at Colorado State University. And he noted that a warmer, more arid climate dries out soil and pulls moisture from plants, making them more susceptible to wildfire. “That thirstier atmosphere is a big concern,” he said.

Forests also absorb planet-warming carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Bigger, older trees store more carbon than younger trees and shrubs. The loss of conifer forests today means a hotter tomorrow.

To better understand these cascading effects, Dr. Hansen and Johan Eckdahl, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of California, Berkeley, visited the Sierra Nevada this month. On a 100-foot hillside plot that burned in the 2022 Oak fire, they recorded each flowering plant and shrub, filled plastic bags with soil, and checked the ground moisture and temperature with a special probe.

Dr. Eckdahl collected soil samples to be examined for indicators of forest health like organic matter and fungus.

Under normal conditions, seedlings would sprout all over after a fire. Young trees would grow and compete for space, water and light, and the forest would return after a decade or two. But the combination of more intense fires and a warmer, drier climate has stopped this age-old process of regeneration.

As Dr. Hansen stood among the brush at the research site, the absence of new growth was stark. “We haven’t found one ponderosa seedling,” he said. “Ponderosa seeds have adapted to fire. That’s how they live. But the fires are just too hot for them.”

Even if seedlings do take hold, they face tough odds. Across the Sierra Nevadas, about one-fifth of the conifers, or cone-bearing trees, are not well suited to the current warming climate.

Dr. Hansen grew up in Bozeman, Mont., on the edge of the Custer Gallatin National Forest. A wildfire in 2000, when he was 13, forced his family to evacuate. “Firefighters saved our home,” Dr. Hansen said. It was frightening, he recalled. But soon after, he noticed something hopeful.

“I remember the next year going out in those woods and hiking around and exploring and seeing little tree seedlings popping up,” he said. “I had this realization that there’s this revitalization effect of forest fire.”

Today, in addition to his work at the Cary Institute, Dr. Hansen directs the Western Fire and Forest Resilience Collaborative, a group of 40 researchers who are using remote satellite sensing, 3-D mapping and computer models that simulate future climate conditions to track the health of western forests.

This summer, survey crews hired by the collaborative are mapping the severity of fires at more than 100 sites in California, Colorado and New Mexico. The goal is to guide researchers trying to better understand how moisture, nutrients and soil microbes influence to what extent forests will recover and how long it will take.

That survey led Dr. Hansen and Dr. Eckdahl to a second site this month, up a winding dirt road about an hour’s drive north from the hillside plot where they collected samples. This area burned in the 2013 Rim fire. At the time it was the largest ever recorded in California, but now it’s only No. 12 on the list.

Dr. Eckdahl said the trees and shrubs at this site were in a struggle of sorts. Some ponderosa pines have survived, new ones are sprouting up, and a tangle of manzanita, oak and shrubs found at lower elevations are trying to establish a foothold.

Both research sites are at the same elevation, about 3,800 feet, and get the same amount of yearly rainfall. But by using a genetic test, Dr. Eckdahl found that the soil at the Rim fire site was richer, with 1.5 times as much organic matter, four times as much bacteria, and six and a half times as much fungus. The Rim fire soils were also high in important nutrients like nitrogen and phosphorus, vital for plant growth.

“Here, the balance between trees and shrubs is equilibrated,” Dr. Eckdahl said of the Rim fire site. “As the climate shifts, we expect that equilibrium to shift, so more of the area will become shrubs. In science we call that the tipping point.”

Once he returns to his campus lab, Dr. Eckdahl will be poring through 260 pounds of dirt from the summer field sites, swabbing DNA from nearly 500 soil samples. He’s already identified 60,000 different bacteria and fungi that are key to understanding which areas will regrow or fail. He said he hoped to create a microbiological atlas of forest health throughout the West.

Across the Southwest, which is drier and subject to more prolonged droughts than other areas like as the Pacific Northwest, ponderosa pine forests are particularly at risk of failing, according to Jonathan Coop, a fire ecologist at Western Colorado University who has been tracking this ecological shift for the past two decades. He, too, grew up in a forest playground, the Jemez Mountains in northern New Mexico, a region that has burned twice since the 1970s and is now nearly barren of trees.

“Watching those forests erode away and turn into something else has really been the catalyst of a lot of the work that I’ve been doing,” Dr. Coop said. “There’s no sign, almost, that there were ever forests there, let alone that they’re coming back. You know, absent a few charred sort of matchstick-like snags.”

This month, Dr. Coop and colleagues published a new study in the journal Science Advances that found wildfires are now getting so large and so fast that pine seeds can’t regenerate. The team looked at almost 3,500 wildfires from 2012 to 2023 in conifer forests in Canada and the Western United States.

“Forests do have innate resilience and under normal circumstances, they can take a hit or two and bounce back,” Dr. Coop said. “But circumstances just aren’t normal anymore.”

As natural regeneration falters, scientists and conservationists are trying to give forests a helping hand.

In Montana, for example, they’re teaming up to plant more climate-resistant seedlings from lower and warmer elevations in new areas that have burned. Kimberley Davis, a research ecologist at the U.S. Forest Service in Missoula, Mont., worked with Conservation International, a nonprofit environmental group based in Arlington, Va., at an experiment in the western part of the state.

They took seedlings of the western larch, a native conifer that can reach 200 feet tall, from 3,400 feet and planted them in a burned area between 4,600 feet and 6,200 feet. The lower-elevation seedlings grew back better and coped with the warmer climate better than seedlings taken from higher elevations. Similar experiments of so-called assisted migration are underway in California and Washington State.

“Keeping as many live trees as we can on the landscape when it burns is really important,” Dr. Davis said. “Because the seed source is so important.”

All the researchers said that there’s still a fair amount of uncertainty in predicting which pine forests will survive and which ones will perish. Despite the new tools of machine learning, remote sensing and genetic analysis, it’s still hard to identify a recipe for a successful forest.

Scientists make calculations based on temperature, moisture and other factors, Dr. Hatchett said, “but the plants are doing their own thing.”

“Biology is always going to throw you a curveball,” he said.

A version of this article appears in print on Aug. 23, 2026, Section A, Page 21 of the New York edition with the headline: Bigger and Hotter Fires Are Erasing America’s Great Forests. Order Reprints | Today’s Paper | Subscribe

Our Coverage of Climate and the Environment


Related Content

More in Climate

Notable new wildfire (#HawkFire) burning just above Verdi/NW of Reno, NV and poses an imminent structure threat as it moves primarily toward NE under Red Flag fire conditions (hot, dry, and windy). Winds are not extreme, but overall burning conditions are greatly elevated. #NVwx

Daniel Swain (@weatherwest.bsky.social) 2026-08-22T19:30:31.000Z

Hawk fire near Reno is another example of rapid growth of a fire during the night. The Hawk fire started yesterday and was over 10,000 acres by 8am this morning. We are seeing more fires burn actively through the night.www.latimes.com/california/s…

Mike Flannigan (@mikeflannigan.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T17:53:28.366Z

"Across the West, drought update states that the combination of a record-low snowpack, record hot temperatures and the unremarkable start to the monsoon season are stressing water supplies." via @theaspentimes.bsky.social at www.aspentimes.com/news/colorad…

Zack Labe (@zacklabe.com) 2026-08-23T12:51:48.450Z

It appears that 2024 will retain its record for warmest day globally (with 2023 coming in 2nd), while 2026 establishes a new record for warmest oceans from 60N-60S: pulse.climate.copernicus.eu

Michael E. Mann (@michaelemann.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T14:18:29.582Z

“All effects combined, we should see some eye-opening weather, perhaps even events to a level we have not experienced before.www.washingtonpost.com/weather/2026…

Jeff Berardelli (@weatherprof.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T13:55:18.977Z

I enjoyed my podcast conversation with David Helvarg on The Rising Tide podcast–but this edited transcript succinctly emphasizes the deep and fundamental relationship between global oceans and the Earth's climate. We do live on a water planet, after all!

Daniel Swain (@weatherwest.bsky.social) 2026-08-21T20:47:34.000Z

This shows the days per year with marginal heat stress in orange, and coral bleaching heat stress in red in the Florida Keys. Both the intensity and longevity of heat stress per summer is increasing.

Jeff Berardelli (@weatherprof.bsky.social) 2026-08-22T18:55:26.532Z

On Wed, Sep 2 at 5:30pm PT I'll giving a talk as part of the California State Library virtual program on CA weather extremes in the context of climate change & this year's very strong El Niño event. The event is free/open to public with registration!

Daniel Swain (@weatherwest.bsky.social) 2026-08-21T20:28:53.000Z

I've heard thousands of climate denial arguments over the last few decades. But do you know they all fall into one of 5 categories?1. It's not real2. It's not us3. It's not bad4. We can't fix it5. You can't trust the info/expertsSource: www.nature.com/articles/s41…

Katharine Hayhoe (@katharinehayhoe.com) 2026-08-23T16:31:50.435Z

Every argument above has the same goal: to delay climate action as long as possible. The only way forward is to abandon this list entirely. If someone brings up an objection, answer it briefly – then pivot immediately to how climate solutions will give us a better future, and we all want that.

Katharine Hayhoe (@katharinehayhoe.com) 2026-08-23T16:34:19.666Z

I know what you're thinking: What about argument X? Trust me, I've heard argument X. (Skeptical Science has documented responses to 252 individual objections below.)I bet it falls into one of the categories above. Think about it!skepticalscience.com/argument.php

Katharine Hayhoe (@katharinehayhoe.com) 2026-08-23T16:32:44.853Z

🥶 Florida may be the Coolest place on Earth this winter, relative to normal! Really! Just the news we need after a sweltering week! The models show a very cool winter ahead in the Southeast and #Florida… 1/

Jeff Berardelli (@weatherprof.bsky.social) 2026-08-21T12:14:05.987Z

I was part of the poll, and picked Katrina (2005), 1900 Galveston, 1926 Great Miami, and Maria (2017) in Puerto Rico.

Dr. Jeff Masters (@drjeffmasters.bsky.social) 2026-08-22T00:09:35.381Z

Energy prices are set globally and there is not enough oil or gas in the North Sea to have any impact, so there would be no reduction in UK bills whatever the country did. www.theguardian.com/environment/…

Dr Paul Dorfman (@drpauldorfman.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T08:59:58.201Z

12/ Early defossilisation, illustrated in the BPSs, leads to early phase-out of fossil fuels, prioritises RE technologies and achieves 5-10% lower cumulative energy system CO2 emissions.

Christian Breyer (@christianonre.bsky.social) 2024-12-23T13:51:09.122Z

Plug-in solar: could a low-cost panel cut your bills?Britons will be able to buy ‘balcony’ systems they can install themselves from 27 August thanks to rule changewww.theguardian.com/money/2026/a…

Dr Paul Dorfman (@drpauldorfman.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T08:55:28.474Z

Onshore windfarm applications hit 10-year high in EnglandSurge in proposals follows Labour’s lifting of de facto ban, with about 45 plans submitted in the year to Marchwww.theguardian.com/environment/…

Dr Paul Dorfman (@drpauldorfman.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T08:53:50.526Z

New nuclear – too late, too costly for climate and energy crises.bennettinstitutesussex.org/stories/nucl…

Dr Paul Dorfman (@drpauldorfman.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T10:06:25.987Z

And #Italy is considering new #nuclear …Nuclear in an active seismic region – perhaps not such a good idea.www.theguardian.com/world/2026/a…

Dr Paul Dorfman (@drpauldorfman.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T09:33:10.741Z

Construction costs and financing of new nuclear power plants in Switzerlandscnat.ch/en/uuid/i/5e…

Dr Paul Dorfman (@drpauldorfman.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T13:29:49.885Z

Swiss Academies of Sciences:New build nuclear costs 20 to 30 % higher than estimates that consider only the pure construction costs. These account for around 70 % of the total costs over the plant's service life.www.bernerzeitung.ch/akw-neubau-s…

Dr Paul Dorfman (@drpauldorfman.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T10:29:26.328Z

Ulez was politically toxic – but now there’s proof that children have healthier lungs. observer.co.uk/news/politic…

Dr Paul Dorfman (@drpauldorfman.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T08:56:51.806Z

Tl;dr.No.www.wired.com/story/is-exp…

Peter Gleick (@petergleick.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T15:50:21.948Z

Your periodic reminder that one in 300 Americans died of COVID, and mostly because they didn't get the miracle vaccine our scientists produced in record time.

Peter Gleick (@petergleick.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T05:45:16.570Z

Nukes all around? A fraying U.S. nuclear umbrella is pushing allies to weigh defense options, raising risk of a proliferation cascade. CNBC 19th Aug 2026www.cnbc.com/2026/08/19/n…

Dr Paul Dorfman (@drpauldorfman.bsky.social) 2026-08-23T08:49:39.429Z

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *