Extreme Temperature Diary-June 12, 2019/ Bolsonaro..How The South American Trump Is Negatively Impacting The Environment

Wednesday June 12th … Dear Diary. The main purpose of this ongoing blog will be to track United States extreme or record temperatures related to climate change. Any reports I see of ETs will be listed below the main topic of the day. I’ll refer to extreme or record temperatures as ETs (not extraterrestrials).😉

Bolsonaro…How The South American Trump Is Negatively Affecting The Environment

I warned last year how Bolsonaro’s election would undermine the environment by greatly cutting back central government authority in Brazil to regulate what happens to the Amazon forest. Now those warnings are coming to fruition. Oligarchs, of which Bolsonaro is a member, appear to be multiplying and gaining power around the globe much to the chagrin of those wanting more democratic forms of government. Some have pegged Trump as being an oligarch, but he is held in check by the U.S. Constitution.

These capitalistic oligarchs seem to have a very short term world view, not planning for long term environmental problems stemming from their policies. For today’s main subject I am reposting news in association with what Bolsonaro is beginning to do with the Amazon, which some have described as the world’s lungs:

https://desdemonadespair.net/2019/06/brazil-guts-environmental-agencies-clears-way-for-unchecked-deforestation-if-before-staff-were-already-being-attacked-by-loggers-imagine-what-it-is-like-with-the-president.html

Brazil guts environmental agencies, clears way for unchecked deforestation – “If before, staff were already being attacked by loggers, imagine what it is like with the president’s endorsement of the criminals”

The number of forest protection operations by Brazil’s federal parks protector, ICMBio (the Chico Mendes Institute) declined heavily in 2019 as the government of President Jair Bolsonaro open the amazon rainforest to unrestricted poaching, agriculture, and mining. Graphic: ICMBio

The number of forest protection operations by Brazil’s federal parks protector, ICMBio (the Chico Mendes Institute) declined heavily in 2019 as the government of President Jair Bolsonaro open the amazon rainforest to unrestricted poaching, agriculture, and mining. Graphic: ICMBio

By Sue Branford and Thais Borges
10 June 2019

(Mongabay) – The Brazilian government’s environmental agency, IBAMA, has so far this year imposed the lowest number of fines for illegal deforestation in at least 11 years, while the country’s other leading environmental agency and its federal parks’ protector, ICMBio (the Chico Mendes Institute), did not carry out any operations at all to monitor deforestation in May.

These developments, reported by the organizations themselves, reflect the extent to which the country’s environmental policies and law enforcement agencies are being dismantled by the government of President Jair Bolsonaro.

Fines for illegal deforestation were down 34 percent from Jan. 1 to May 15 this year, compared to the same period last year, according to the O Estado de S. Paulo newspaper. This is the largest percentage drop ever recorded in Brazil. In absolute terms, it marks the smallest number of fines ever (850), compared to 1,290 imposed over the same period in 2018.

The last year in which a comparable number of fines (952) were imposed during the same period was 2012 — but this was at a time when real advances were being made in the fight against illegal deforestation. Indeed, 2012 was the year with the lowest level of deforestation in the Brazil Amazon since records began.

This is far from being the case today. Recent figures on illegal deforestation, published by the National Institute of Spatial Research (INPE) and confirmed by the federal government, show that the Amazon region recorded the highest level ever of illegal deforestation for a single month in May 2019: 739 square kilometers (285 square miles), an area nearly as large as New York City. This is a 34 percent increase on the area cleared in May 2018, which was 550 square kilometers (212 square miles). It seems likely that the rise stems from government policies favorable to deforestation.

This confirms what an unnamed IBAMA official told Mongabay before the recent INPE figures were published: “It’s very difficult to believe that the decline in fines reflects a decline in illegal deforestation.” Agency employees spoke to Mongabay on background, citing fear of reprisals from the Bolsonaro administration. IBAMA’s press office told Mongabay that its request for an on-the-record interview should be sent to the Ministry of the Environment, but the ministry did not respond, despite multiple Mongabay requests.

Illegal timber harvest seizures drop toward zero

Government seizures of illegally harvested timber fell even more dramatically than the number of fines: just 40 cubic meters (1,410 cubic feet), equivalent to 10 large trees, were confiscated in the first four months of the year under Bolsonaro. By contrast, 25,000 cubic meters (883,000 cubic feet) of illegal timber were seized in 2018 under the Michel Temer administration.

It seems unlikely the volume of seizures will increase by much in the near future: all six monitoring operations planned for coming months have either been cancelled or downsized.

And those that do go ahead are likely to yield few results: IBAMA’s website must now announce in advance when and where each operation will take place, even though it’s obvious that the success of the raids depends on secrecy and the element of surprise. This advance publicity also increases the risks to IBAMA agents, leaving them more vulnerable to criminal attacks.

Mass firings leave environmental agencies leaderless

According to experts, the disarray at IBAMA is largely due to the firing of the heads of the agency’s state bodies, which carry out most of the deforestation-monitoring operations. In February, Environment Minister Ricardo Salles axed 21 of the 27 state superintendents in a single day. To date, only four of the state bodies have official heads. Without leadership, there is no proper planning for operations to curb illegal deforestation.

It’s these state superintendents who have the authority to make decisions regarding the charging of smaller fines, those up to 500,000 reais ($129,000), which constitute the majority of fines. “The employees who occupy the top posts temporarily do not feel they have the authority to take such decisions,” said another IBAMA employee.

In President Jair Bolsonaro’s first 100 days, his administration weakened environmental protections and institutions, while the Amazon saw an uptick in violence against indigenous groups and traditional communities. Photo: Palácio do Planalto / CC BY 2.0

In President Jair Bolsonaro’s first 100 days, his administration weakened environmental protections and institutions, while the Amazon saw an uptick in violence against indigenous groups and traditional communities. Photo: Palácio do Planalto / CC BY 2.0

Morale is also very low at the environmental agency, with both Salles and Bolsonaro repeatedly attacking IBAMA. One incident that greatly affected employees was Bolsonaro’s surprise announcement that IBAMA agents could no longer set fire to tractors and other equipment used by illegal loggers. This legally approved policy had long been an effective deterrent for IBAMA agents to combat criminal deforestation in remote areas where it’s both difficult and expensive to confiscate illicit equipment.

In a short video interview, Bolsonaro, standing beside Marcos Rogério, a right-wing senator from Rondônia state, banned operations to end the illegal extraction of timber from Jamari National Forest, a protected area in Rondônia that is being extensively invaded by illegal loggers and land grabbers. That presidential statement was enough to not only stop all government monitoring operations in the forest, but also make IBAMA officials fear potential assaults if they set foot in the protected area, an official said.

“If before the video, staff were already being attacked by loggers, imagine what it is like with the president’s endorsement of the criminals,” an IBAMA employee said. In practice, the government’s new policies have forced a host of highly skilled environmental officials to be paid to sit idle and not uphold the nation’s deforestation laws. [more]

Brazil guts environmental agencies, clears way for unchecked deforestation

An even more scary facet of this news is that young people like Greta Thunberg can protest until they turn blue, but their actions won’t make any difference if leaders like Bolsonaro hold power in key environmental locations on the planet, such as the Amazon. Would be strong men and dictators can circumvent democratic actions and protests such that future elections won’t matter either. I’m afraid that a true green revolution in Brazil will be the only thing that can turn the situation in the Amazon around as demanded by a vast majority of citizens. The people of Brazil will need to lead that revolution, but probably won’t see the need until it’s way too late due to what I’m sure will be short term economic gain from logging and drilling. That revolution may be many years off but I hope will be bloodless.

Here is more climate and weather news from Wednesday.

(As usual, this will be a fluid post in which more information gets added during the day as it crosses my radar, crediting all who have put it on-line. Items will be archived on this site for posterity. In most instances click on the pictures of each tweet to see each article.)

Here are Wednesday’s ET’s:

(If you like these posts and my work please contribute via the PayPal widget, which has recently been added to this site. Thanks in advance for any support.) 

Guy Walton- “The Climate Guy”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.